AI is scaling retail media creative, but community signals may determine whether it actually works

Published

This summary was written by ShopDigest AI from InternetRetailing’s report, by Paul Skeldon. Read the full story ↗

New research suggests that the volume of creative being generated by AI is increasing much faster than its quality.

Overview

Generative AI is increasing the volume of retail media creative faster than its quality, according to new research from WARC and LIONS Advisory. Only 45% of marketers say AI has significantly improved creative quality, while 88% say it has increased volume. The report suggests combining AI with community intelligence—live signals from searches, comments, shares, and purchases—to make creative more effective.

Key Details

  • 90% of marketers say AI is part of the creative toolkit; 88% say it increased creative volume.
  • Only 45% say AI significantly improved creative quality.
  • 67% of marketers still use demographics as the primary AI prompt input, despite 59% agreeing demographics are no longer effective.
  • Only 17% always incorporate community or audience insights beyond demographics into AI workflows.
  • 86% say real-time audience behavior and community signals are important to creative development.

Why It Matters

Retailers risk producing more ads that are less relevant if they rely solely on AI without community signals. Combining commerce data with cultural and behavioral insights can make creative more responsive to actual customer demand, potentially improving campaign performance and advertiser outcomes.

Frequently asked questions

What does the WARC and LIONS Advisory research say about AI and creative quality?

The research found that while 88% of marketers say generative AI has increased the volume of creative they produce, only 45% say it has significantly improved creative quality. This suggests AI is scaling output faster than it is improving effectiveness.

Why are community signals important for retail media creative?

Community signals—such as searches, comments, shares, reviews, and creator content—can reveal emerging demand and cultural trends before they show up in sales data. Combining these signals with AI can make creative more responsive to what customers actually want, rather than just faster to produce.

What percentage of marketers use demographics as a primary input for AI creative?

According to the research, 67% of marketers cite demographics as the most common input when prompting AI for creative. This is despite 59% agreeing that traditional demographic segmentation is no longer effective.

How can retailers use community intelligence to improve advertising?

Retailers can layer community intelligence on top of their own transaction and search data to understand why demand is changing and how customers talk about their needs. This can inform creative messaging, product selection, merchandising, and how retail media networks package audiences for advertisers.

About this story

Topics covered
Published
20 Jul 2026
Originally published at