How to Acquire and Retain Subscribers, According to Recurly’s Rachel Sheriff
- Topic
- Subscriptions
- Source
- Retail TouchPoints
- Published
This summary was written by ShopDigest AI from Retail TouchPoints’s report, by Kate Robertson. Read the full story ↗
With clients like Nuuly and Paramount, Recurly's Rachel Sheriff shares tips on subscriber retention through subscription flexibility, smart personalization and a seamless customer experience.
Overview
Recurly's Rachel Sheriff says subscription acquisition rates have fallen 51% since 2019, but the market is maturing rather than retreating. The bigger challenge for subscription businesses is now retention, with roughly 52% of consumers canceling at least one subscription in the past 12 months. Pause features and flexible, personalized experiences are emerging as practical churn-reduction tools.
Key Numbers
- Subscription acquisition rates dropped from 6.23% in 2019 to just over 3%.
- Pause adoption grew 150% year over year.
- Three out of four subscribers who pause return within months.
- About 52% of consumers canceled at least one subscription in the past 12 months.
- The most common cancellation reason was not using the subscription enough.
Why It Matters
- Retention has replaced acquisition as the primary challenge for subscription businesses.
- Consumers are curating a portfolio of subscriptions based on recurring value, not abandoning the model.
- Pause options keep billing information on file and maintain an ongoing relationship with the subscriber.
- Nuuly succeeds through affordability, flexibility, broad product range, and sustainability appeal.
- Recurly's Engage product supports the full customer lifecycle from onboarding to re-engagement.
Frequently asked questions
How much have subscription acquisition rates dropped since 2019?
According to data collected by Recurly, subscription acquisition rates have dropped 51% since 2019, falling from 6.23% to just over 3%. Rachel Sheriff, Recurly's Chief Customer Officer, frames this as a maturing market rather than consumers walking away from subscriptions. She says consumers are being more intentional about which subscriptions they pay for month over month.
Why is retention now harder than acquisition for subscription businesses?
Sheriff says that about five years ago the focus was on acquiring as many subscribers as possible, but the bigger challenge today is keeping existing subscribers. The report found that approximately 52% of consumers canceled at least one subscription in the past 12 months. The most common reason given was that they weren't using it enough.
How does the pause feature help reduce subscription churn?
Pause adoption grew 150% year over year, and three out of four subscribers who pause return within months. Sheriff says allowing a pause keeps the subscriber reachable, with billing information still on file, so brands can continue to provide value and remind them of it. She describes it as a practical churn-reduction tool rather than a loss of revenue.
Why is Nuuly succeeding in fashion rental subscriptions?
Nuuly, the fashion rental service under Urban Outfitters and a Recurly client, succeeds through a combination of affordability, flexibility, and broad product range. Subscribers can select six items per month, add more for a fee, and return items early to refresh their selection. Sheriff also cites sustainability and changing consumer needs, such as GLP-1 medication users, as drivers.
What is Recurly's Engage product used for?
Recurly has built pause functionality into its platform alongside a product called Engage. Engage is designed to support the full customer lifecycle, from onboarding to re-engagement after a cancellation. It helps subscription businesses maintain relationships with subscribers even when they step back temporarily.
