In Graphic Detail: How AI search has impacted the web traffic of over 50 advertisers

Source
Digiday
Published

This summary was written by ShopDigest AI from Digiday’s report, by Sam Bradley. Read the full story ↗

Data spanning one agency’s entire client roster shows the true impact of AI search on web traffic and conversions.

Overview

Data from agency Brainlabs across 54 clients shows Google AI Overviews cut organic web traffic by over 10% on average, while AI referral traffic surged 163%. Despite lower traffic, conversion rates from AI referrals are higher, suggesting users arriving via AI are further along in the buying journey.

Key Details

  • Organic sessions fell from ~20 million to under 15 million per month after AI Overviews appeared on 30%+ of U.S. search results.
  • 46 of 54 clients saw traffic dips; average decline was 10.5%.
  • AI-driven key events rose 335%, with a 1.5x higher conversion rate than organic search.
  • Retail and beauty saw smaller traffic drops and higher AI referral lifts; fitness, fintech, insurance, and CPG saw the largest dips.
  • ChatGPT dominates AI search referrals, with 1 billion monthly active users.

Why It Matters

Ecommerce brands should track AI referrals as a distinct channel and include them in KPIs, not just organic traffic. The shift means fewer but higher-intent visitors, so measuring conversions and key events is critical for paid media planning.

Frequently asked questions

How much did organic web traffic decline after Google AI Overviews?

Brainlabs' data across 54 clients showed organic traffic fell by over 10%, from 140.1 million to 125.4 million sessions over 14 months. The decline became pronounced after AI Overviews appeared on at least 30% of U.S. search results pages in September 2025.

Did AI search traffic lead to more conversions than organic search?

Yes. AI-referred visitors completed key events at 1.5 times the rate of organic search visitors. Key events from AI referrals rose 335% during the measured period, even as overall traffic declined.

Which industries were most and least affected by AI Overviews?

Fitness, fintech, insurance, and CPG brands saw the largest traffic dips, likely due to comparison-heavy purchasing. Retail, beauty, and entertainment clients saw the smallest drops and the highest lifts from AI referrals, as AI Overviews triggered less on transactional searches.

Which AI platform drove the most referral traffic?

ChatGPT accounted for the majority of AI referrals, both before and after September 2025. It reached 1 billion monthly active users in May, compared to Claude's 56 million, according to Sensor Tower.

About this story

Published
25 Aug 2026
Source
Originally published at