Retailers Can’t Afford to Keep Every Delivery Promise This Holiday Season

- Topic
- Fulfillment
- Source
- Mytotalretail.com
- Published
This summary was written by ShopDigest AI from Mytotalretail.com’s report, by Anup Prasad. Read the full story ↗
Faster delivery is becoming an expensive promise to keep. It became a default expectation, but rising delivery costs, high return volumes, and tariff uncertainty are reshaping inventory plans.
Overview
Retailers are finding that fast delivery promises are increasingly expensive to keep as delivery costs, high return volumes, and tariff uncertainty reshape inventory planning. The National Retail Federation estimates holiday returns at about 17 percent of sales, on top of nearly $850 billion in annual industry-wide returns. The article argues retailers must align fulfillment promises with actual inventory, service levels, and store capabilities.
Key Details
- Holiday returns are estimated at about 17 percent of sales, with nearly $850 billion in merchandise returned industry-wide annually.
- Retailers should build a single view of inventory across all fulfillment locations within their order management system.
- Available-to-promise data should reflect the ability to pick, pack, and deliver, not just item location.
- Service levels should vary by product category, customer segment, and geography to protect margins.
- AI-driven order orchestration can weigh inventory, labor, carrier capacity, delivery cost, and expected margin in real time.
- Stores should have clear rules for fulfilling orders, supporting pickup, and processing returns based on value, inventory, labor, and resale path.
Why It Matters
Customers care whether an item is available, arrives when promised, and can be returned easily, regardless of where it ships from. Accurate promise dates can reduce costly exceptions and protect customer trust during peak season. Retailers that fail to align fulfillment economics with customer promises risk eroding margins and disappointing shoppers.
Frequently asked questions
What percentage of holiday sales are returned according to the National Retail Federation?
The National Retail Federation's latest estimate puts holiday returns at about 17 percent of sales. This is on top of nearly $850 billion in merchandise returned industry-wide annually. These figures highlight the significant cost burden of returns for retailers.
Why is faster delivery becoming an expensive promise for retailers?
Faster delivery has become a default customer expectation, but rising delivery costs, high return volumes, and tariff uncertainty are making it harder to sustain profitably. Retailers must now weigh whether expedited fulfillment improves conversion or loyalty against the added expense. In some cases, such as same-day delivery on a low-value order, shipping costs can erase the margin entirely.
How can retailers improve inventory accuracy for fulfillment promises?
Retailers should establish a single view of inventory across all fulfillment locations within their order management system. Maintaining inventory accuracy through frequent reconciliation helps avoid stock discrepancies and fulfillment failures. Incorporating carrier service data, labor capacity, transportation costs, inventory turns, and cost-to-serve metrics into fulfillment decisions makes available-to-promise data more useful.
What role can AI play in order fulfillment during peak season?
AI-driven order orchestration can apply service policies in real time as conditions change. It can continuously weigh inventory location, store labor, carrier capacity, delivery cost, and expected margin, adjusting fulfillment options as capacity tightens. Agentic AI can also flag pickup orders at risk of delay and direct returns to locations where they can be resold or processed at the lowest cost.
How should retailers decide which stores fulfill orders or process returns?
Retailers should set rules for when stores fulfill orders, support pickup, or process returns based on product value, local inventory, staff capacity, transportation costs, and the item's resale path. Stores can lower last-mile and reverse logistics costs, but challenges arise when store teams lack inventory, labor, or space, especially after Christmas when return volume spikes. Using each store strategically helps balance in-store service with fulfillment demands.