SEO vs. GEO: Which to Prioritize?

- Topic
- SEO
- Source
- Practical Ecommerce
- Published
This summary was written by ShopDigest AI from Practical Ecommerce’s report, by Ann Smarty. Read the full story ↗
Organic search should remain the priority until we have proof that AI visibility materially drives purchases.
Overview
The article weighs whether businesses should prioritize traditional SEO or generative engine optimization (GEO) for AI platforms. It argues organic search should remain the priority because Google is the only intent-based, measurable organic channel, while GEO metrics remain a black box and genAI traffic is minimal.
Key Details
- ChatGPT sends very little traffic to websites: 0.43% overall per Ahrefs, with the highest share at 0.70% going to technology sites.
- Search optimizer Marie Haynes argues in her article that GEO is a distraction.
- There are no reliable metrics to gauge the impact of AI visibility alone, and post-purchase surveys asking where customers heard about a brand are imperfect.
- Organic search visibility is described as the most predictable route to AI visibility, though studies conflict on the correlation between top Google rankings and genAI citations.
- ChatGPT tends to cite large publications and user-generated content like Reddit, while Gemini and AI Mode rely on Google's index.
- GEO tactics such as brand awareness on Reddit and inclusion in high-authority listicles also drive traffic and conversions independently of AI platforms.
Frequently asked questions
How much traffic does ChatGPT send to websites?
ChatGPT sends very little traffic to websites: 0.43% overall, according to Ahrefs. The article notes its own data found the highest share, at 0.70%, going to technology sites.
Why should businesses prioritize SEO over GEO?
The article argues SEO should be the priority because Google is the only intent-based, measurable organic search channel, while GEO metrics remain a black box. It also states organic search visibility is the most predictable route to AI visibility.
What does Marie Haynes say about GEO?
Search optimizer Marie Haynes argues in her article that GEO is a distraction. The article references her study along with two others summarized by Search Engine Roundtable.
What sources do genAI platforms cite?
ChatGPT tends to cite large publications, many of which are OpenAI partners, and user-generated content such as Reddit. Gemini and AI Mode rely on Google's index.
How can businesses measure AI visibility impact?
The article says there are no reliable metrics to gauge the impact of visibility alone on genAI platforms. Post-purchase surveys asking where customers heard about a brand are imperfect because buyers with extended journeys may not recall a genAI mention.
Do GEO tactics provide benefits beyond AI visibility?
The article states that everything done for GEO results in additional benefits. For example, brand awareness on Reddit drives traffic and conversions with or without ChatGPT, and inclusion in high-authority listicles also spurs traffic and conversions.

