Study shows Instacart may be charging some shoppers 20% more for the same product

Published

This summary was written by ShopDigest AI from TechCrunch Ecommerce’s report, by Lucas Ropek. Read the full story ↗

The delivery app has claimed that price testing is part of a longstanding practice in retail sales.

Overview

Consumer Reports and Groundwork Collaborative found that Instacart's AI-led pricing experiments, using Eversight software, can raise product prices by up to 23% for some shoppers at partner retailers like Kroger, Albertsons, Costco, and Safeway. Instacart defends the practice as a limited, randomized test, not dynamic pricing, and says only 10 U.S. retail partners apply markups. The report highlights growing scrutiny of pricing practices in ecommerce and delivery platforms.

Key Details

  • Price increases observed up to 23% for identical products.
  • Eversight is a SaaS pricing suite used by grocers to optimize prices.
  • Instacart says tests are randomized, not based on personal data, and prices never change in real-time.
  • Similar dynamic pricing concerns have been raised about Amazon's school supply pricing.

Why It Matters

For ecommerce professionals, this underscores the ethical and reputational risks of price testing and personalization. Transparent pricing practices are critical to maintaining customer trust, especially as regulators and consumer groups scrutinize algorithmic pricing.

Frequently asked questions

How much more did Instacart charge some shoppers in the pricing tests?

According to a Consumer Reports study, some Instacart shoppers paid as much as 23% more than other shoppers for the exact same product. The study was conducted with research partner Groundwork Collaborative.

What software did Instacart use for its pricing experiments?

Instacart used Eversight, a SaaS product that offers grocers a retail pricing suite. Eversight is designed to help retailers scale their pricing strategy and uncover optimal prices.

Which retailers were involved in Instacart's pricing tests?

The pricing experiments took place at Instacart's retail partner locations, including Kroger, Albertsons, Costco, and Safeway. Instacart said only 10 U.S. retail partners that already apply markups were involved.

Did Instacart deny using dynamic pricing?

Yes, Instacart disputed the characterization of its activity as dynamic pricing. The company called it an 'AI-enabled pricing experiment' and said prices never change in real-time or in response to supply and demand, and that tests are completely randomized.

About this story

Published
16 Dec 2025
Originally published at