Cart Pencil Shopify App – Benchmarks vs Category Leaders
(Updated October 2026) Compare Cart Pencil head-to-head with the top apps in Cart customization on the Shopify App Store — current rank, 30-day average, best position over the period, and a long-term trajectory chart so you can see whether Cart Pencil is closing the gap with leaders, holding steady, or losing ground. Edit variants in cart: reduce abandonment and returns with sticky add-to-cart bar and custom drawer.
Cart Pencil vs Top Apps in Cart customization on Shopify
Side-by-side comparison of Cart Pencil against the top 4 apps in the Cart customization category — current rank, 30-day average, and best position over the period. Switch the Group Selector to benchmark in any other group Cart Pencil ranks in; switch the page-level sub-tab for Market Share or Reviews columns instead.
| App | Rank | Average | Best |
|---|---|---|---|
 Cart PencilCURRENT APP | N/A | N/A | N/A |
 ETP Sort Hide Payment Methods | 14 | 10.16 | 1 |
 Kaching CartDrawer Cart Upsell | 21 | 2.03 | 1 |
 Kaching Post Purchase Upsell | 31 | 5.87 | 3 |
 EG Auto Add to Cart Free Gift | 42 | 5.45 | 3 |
Key Insights:
- Direct competitors: ETP Sort Hide Payment Methods, Kaching CartDrawer Cart Upsell, Kaching Post Purchase Upsell.
Cart Pencil — Rankings Trend vs Leaders in Cart customization
Monthly rank trajectory for Cart Pencil alongside the top 4 apps in the Cart customization category over the past year — see whether Cart Pencil is closing the gap with the leaders, holding steady, or losing ground. Y-axis is reversed so rank #1 sits at the top.
Charts Data
| App | May 2026 | Jun 2026 | Jul 2026 | Aug 2026 | Sep 2026 | Oct 2026 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ETP Sort Hide Payment Methods | #6 | #33 | #3 | #41 | #22 | #11 |
| Kaching CartDrawer Cart Upsell | #3 | #21 | #2 | #2 | #11 | #21 |
| Kaching Post Purchase Upsell | #7 | #61 | #6 | #51 | #32 | #3 |
| EG Auto Add to Cart Free Gift | #5 | #41 | #51 | #61 | #6 | #42 |
| Cart PencilCURRENT APP | — | — | — | — | — | — |
Key Insights:
- Cart Pencil held #94 in Cart customization across the charted period.
- Gap to ETP Sort Hide Payment Methods widened by 12 positions — leader is pulling away.
- Across the 5 apps plotted, 4 improved rank and 0 declined.
Cart Pencil — Head-to-Head vs Leaders in Cart customization
Cart Pencil appears in the Cart customization category on the Shopify App Store — the comparison table above shows where it sits versus the leaders. Direct competitors on this view include ETP Sort Hide Payment Methods, Kaching CartDrawer Cart Upsell and Kaching Post Purchase Upsell.
Cart Pencil — Long-Term Ranking Trajectory vs Leaders in Cart customization
Cart Pencil held #94 in Cart customization steadily across the charted period — entrenched against the leaders on this view. The gap to ETP Sort Hide Payment Methods (#1) has widened by 12 positions — ETP Sort Hide Payment Methods is pulling away. Across the 5 apps plotted, 4 improved their rank and 0 declined over the charted window.
Top Categories Cart Pencil Ranks In on Shopify
- Keywordbuy buttons — Ranks #62 in this Shopify keyword.
- KeywordCheckout customization — Ranks #75 in this Shopify keyword.
- Keywordslide cart — Ranks #79 in this Shopify keyword.
- Keywordsticky add to cart — Ranks #81 in this Shopify keyword.
Cart Pencil on Shopify — Benchmarks FAQs
1. Which apps does Cart Pencil compete with on Shopify?
Cart Pencil's closest competitors in Cart customization on the Shopify App Store include ETP Sort Hide Payment Methods, Kaching CartDrawer Cart Upsell, Kaching Post Purchase Upsell and EG Auto Add to Cart Free Gift. Use the App Selector on the comparison table above to swap competitors in or out, or the Group Selector to benchmark Cart Pencil in a different category, keyword, or collection.
2. Is Cart Pencil closing the gap on category leaders?
Not currently — over the charted period, Cart Pencil's gap to ETP Sort Hide Payment Methods (#1) has widened by 12 positions in Cart customization. Cross-reference with the page-level Market Share sub-tab to see whether share is moving differently.
3. How does Cart Pencil's benchmark comparison work on ShopDigest?
The comparison table loads Cart Pencil alongside the top apps in its strongest Shopify category (Cart customization by default) and shows current rank, 30-day average rank, and best ranking over the period. Switch the Group Selector to compare in any other category, keyword, or collection Cart Pencil appears in. Switch the page-level sub-tab to swap rank columns for market share % or cumulative review counts of the same comparison set.
4. Can I benchmark Cart Pencil against apps in a different category?
Yes — use the Group Selector on the comparison table to pick any of the categories, keywords, or collections Cart Pencil ranks in. Switching the group reloads both cards together with the new comparison set; switching the page-level sub-tab (Rankings / Market Share / Reviews) swaps the metric in lock-step across both cards.
