AI recommendations are leading to returns

- Topic
- Returns
- Source
- Retail Dive
- Published
This summary was written by ShopDigest AI from Retail Dive’s report, by Nicole Silberstein. Read the full story ↗
The problem may not have to do with the technology itself, but rather the product description data, according to a new report.
Overview
A Blue Yonder survey of 2,000 U.S. shoppers found that nearly a quarter have bought a product based on an AI recommendation, and 46% of those buyers returned an item in the past year. The most common reason for returning an AI-recommended purchase was that the item was different than described (36%), ahead of incorrect size or fit (23%). Blue Yonder's CEO attributes the problem to product description data rather than the AI technology itself.
Key Details
- 36% of AI-recommendation returns were because the item was different than described; 23% cited incorrect size or fit.
- Incorrect size or fit is the top reason for U.S. returns overall at 42%.
- 51% of respondents said they chose one retailer over another purely for a better returns policy.
- 29% stopped shopping at a retailer that tightened its return policy in the past year.
- 43% of Gen Z bought based on an AI recommendation, versus 36% of millennials, 19% of Gen X and 9% of baby boomers.
- 89% of shoppers in a separate SmartCustomer survey don't fully trust AI recommendations.
Why It Matters
AI assistants are finding the right fit better than traditional channels, but they struggle to describe products accurately because most product data was written for search bars rather than machine-driven suggestions. Shoppers are adopting AI recommendations faster than retailers are preparing their product data, and restrictive return policies push customers to competitors.
Frequently asked questions
Why are AI-recommended purchases being returned so often?
Among U.S. shoppers who returned an AI-recommended purchase, 36% said the item was different than described and 23% cited an incorrect size or fit. Blue Yonder's CEO says the root cause is product description data, not the AI technology, since assistants can only work with the product information retailers provide.
What percentage of shoppers buy based on AI recommendations?
Nearly a quarter of U.S. consumers have bought a product based on an AI recommendation, according to the Blue Yonder survey of 2,000 shoppers. Adoption is highest among Gen Z at 43%, compared to 36% of millennials, 19% of Gen X and 9% of baby boomers.
How much do return policies influence where shoppers buy?
Over half of U.S. respondents (51%) said they have chosen one retailer over another purely because it had a better returns policy. Nearly a third (29%) said they stopped shopping altogether at a retailer that implemented a stricter return policy in the past year.
Do shoppers trust AI product recommendations?
Trust remains shaky: a SmartCustomer survey found 89% of shoppers don't fully trust AI recommendations, and a third of those respondents said they made a regrettable purchase based on one. A separate Mastercard survey found nearly a third of teenagers trusted AI-generated product recommendations over a friend.
What is the most common reason for returns overall compared to AI-recommended items?
Incorrect size or fit is the most common factor leading to U.S. returns in general at 42%. For AI-recommended products, the top reason is that the item was different than described (36%), suggesting AI assistants handle fit better but struggle with accurate product descriptions.
