Avoid All-Caps Headlines, Says CRO Pro

- Topic
- Conversion
- Source
- Practical Ecommerce
- Published
This summary was written by ShopDigest AI from Practical Ecommerce’s report, by Eric Bandholz. Read the full story ↗
Nate Lagos tested a client's all-caps headlines and found a simple change lifted conversions by 25%.
Overview
Conversion rate optimizer Nate Lagos shares insights from his A/B testing work, including a surprising finding that switching all-caps headlines to sentence case lifted conversions by 25% for a client. He also discusses his bottoms-up testing approach, which focuses on copy closest to the purchase decision, and advises brands to explore new customer segments as a growth lever.
Key Details
- All-caps headlines tested against sentence case produced a 25% increase in conversions on a high-traffic landing page.
- Lagos recommends testing copy near the add-to-cart button, such as headlines and product pages, before top-of-funnel ads.
- He uses Intelligems for A/B testing and aims for 80% or higher statistical significance.
- At Original Grain, targeting women as gift buyers grew their share of customers from 50% to 80%.
Why It Matters
Simple copy changes can have outsized impact on conversion rates. Testing close to the purchase decision reveals buyer intent that can inform broader marketing messages. Expanding target audiences, such as selling men's products to women as gifts, can unlock significant growth without new products.
Frequently asked questions
How much did conversions increase when all-caps headlines were changed?
Changing all-caps headlines to title case (capitalizing only the first letter of each word) increased conversions by 25% on a high-traffic landing page. The test also lowered cost per acquisition for the client.
What is bottoms-up testing in conversion rate optimization?
Bottoms-up testing focuses on copy closest to the purchase decision, such as headlines, product detail pages, and home pages, rather than top-of-funnel advertising. The goal is to learn what entices buyers to purchase or bounce, then apply those insights to broader ad messaging.
How did Original Grain grow by targeting women?
Original Grain discovered that about half of its customers were women, yet their messaging only targeted men. By hiring a female marketer and creating campaigns aimed at women buying gifts for husbands and boyfriends, they grew women to 80% of their customer base.
What tools does Nate Lagos use for A/B testing?
Nate Lagos uses Intelligems to A/B test copy on-site, in emails, and in ad accounts. He aims for statistical significance with an 80% or higher likelihood of beating the control, requiring tens of thousands of site visitors and thousands of orders.


