California’s Subscription Laws Gain Another Victory

- Topic
- Subscriptions
- Source
- Paymentsjournal.com
- Published
This summary was written by ShopDigest AI from Paymentsjournal.com’s report, by Tom Nawrocki. Read the full story ↗
HelloFresh will pay $7.5 million for a civil lawsuit in California, which alleged it deceptively enrolled users into auto-renewal plans.
Overview
HelloFresh will pay $7.5 million to settle a California lawsuit alleging deceptive auto-renewal practices, violating the state's Automatic Renewal Law and False Advertising Law. The case highlights growing state-level scrutiny of subscription models, with California and New York tightening requirements. Businesses using subscriptions must ensure clear disclosure, affirmative consent, and easy cancellation.
Key Details
- HelloFresh settlement: $7.5 million, no admission of liability.
- Allegations: unclear terms, no consent before charging, difficult cancellation.
- California law now requires annual reminders and cancellation via the same channel used for sign-up.
- New York's stricter rules take effect in November, requiring disclosure before consent.
- Federal 'click-to-cancel' rule was blocked by a court, shifting focus to state laws.
Why It Matters
Subscription-based merchants must proactively review their enrollment and cancellation flows to comply with evolving state regulations. Non-compliance risks significant fines and legal action. Staying ahead of these laws is critical for customer trust and operational stability.
Frequently asked questions
What did HelloFresh settle in California?
HelloFresh agreed to pay $7.5 million to settle a civil lawsuit in California. The suit alleged the company deceptively enrolled consumers into auto-renewing subscription plans without proper disclosure or consent, violating the state's Automatic Renewal Law and False Advertising Law. HelloFresh admitted no liability in the settlement.
What are the new requirements under California's Auto Renewal Law?
Recent updates to California's Auto Renewal Law, effective in July, require businesses to send consumers an annual reminder that clearly states the renewal frequency, the amount to be charged, and step-by-step cancellation instructions. Additionally, businesses must offer cancellation through the same channel the subscription was initiated—for example, if sign-up happened online, cancellation must also be available online, not just by phone.
How does New York's subscription law compare to California's?
New York's restrictions, which take effect in November, are in some ways stricter than California's. Businesses operating in New York must clearly disclose the price and terms of any automatic renewal offer, including detailed cancellation instructions, before they can even request a consumer's consent. This pre-consent disclosure requirement goes beyond California's current rules.
What happened to the FTC's click-to-cancel rule?
A federal appeals court blocked the 'click-to-cancel' subscription rule issued by the Federal Trade Commission during the final months of the Biden administration. This means the FTC rule is not currently in effect, while state-level protections like those in California and New York continue to be enforced.