Email Open Bloat and Deliverability

- Topic
- Marketing
- Source
- Practical Ecommerce
- Published
This summary was written by ShopDigest AI from Practical Ecommerce’s report, by Armando Roggio. Read the full story ↗
A portion of email opens is likely non-human, resulting in "bloat" from unengaged subscribers.
Overview
The article explains how email open rates can be inflated by non-human interactions, such as Apple's Mail Privacy Protection, leading to 'open bloat' where unengaged subscribers remain on active lists. It recommends segmenting out subscribers who appear to open but never click, which typically reduces send volume and open rates while keeping click counts stable, thereby improving deliverability. It also discusses 'lost clickers'—subscribers with older engagement—as a potential segment to test for incremental clicks.
Key Details
- Open bloat occurs when automated opens keep unengaged subscribers in active segments.
- Base sending segments are defined by signup, open, and click windows (e.g., weekly: 30/45/90 days).
- Excluding apparent openers who never click lowers send volume and open rates but leaves click counts unchanged.
- Lost clickers are subscribers who clicked 91–150 days ago and may be worth testing as a separate segment.
Why It Matters
Improving deliverability by removing false-positive engagement helps ensure emails reach the inbox rather than spam folders. This approach can increase click rates and reduce wasted sends to disengaged recipients.
Frequently asked questions
What is email open bloat?
Email open bloat refers to inflated open rates caused by non-human interactions, such as Apple's Mail Privacy Protection automatically loading email content. This makes subscribers appear engaged when they are not, keeping them on active lists and potentially hurting deliverability.
How can I fix open bloat in my email list?
Create a dynamic segment of subscribers who opened within the past week but have never clicked, and exclude them from your base sending segment. This reduces send volume and open rates but keeps click counts stable, improving click rate and deliverability.
What are lost clickers in email marketing?
Lost clickers are subscribers whose last click or open falls outside your standard engagement window, such as 91–150 days ago. They may still be interested, so testing them as a separate segment can recover incremental clicks without increasing complaints.
Why are email open rates considered a vanity metric?
Open rates can be misleading because privacy features and security systems can trigger opens without human action. As a result, high open rates may not reflect real engagement, making clicks a more reliable indicator of interest.
