Email Pro: Open Rate Is a Vanity Metric

Published

This summary was written by ShopDigest AI from Practical Ecommerce’s report, by Eric Bandholz. Read the full story ↗

Agency owner Nabeel Azeez says revenue, not open rates, is paramount and never unsubscribe dormant recipients.

Overview

Email marketing agency owner Nabeel Azeez argues that open rates are a vanity metric and that revenue should be the primary focus. He advocates aggressive email frequency, engagement-based segmentation, and never unsubscribing dormant recipients, instead using reactivation campaigns. The article covers his onboarding process, segmentation strategies, and common mistakes in ecommerce email marketing.

Key Strategies

  • Send a nine-word email to non-buyers to get them to raise their hands.
  • Increase email frequency to daily or even multiple times per day, segmented by engagement and customer value.
  • Segment lists into groups like whales, potential whales, loyal customers, and lapsed whales, with tailored messaging.
  • Use sunset automations for unengaged subscribers but pause rather than unsubscribe, and send periodic reactivation emails.
  • Test opt-in pop-up offers beyond just discounts, such as free products or bundles.

Why It Matters

For ecommerce merchants, this approach challenges conventional email marketing wisdom, emphasizing revenue over engagement metrics. It suggests that aggressive, well-segmented email campaigns can significantly boost revenue, especially when combined with SMS and proper attribution. The advice is actionable for brands looking to scale their email channel.

Frequently asked questions

Why does Nabeel Azeez say open rate is a vanity metric?

Azeez believes that open rates do not directly correlate with revenue, which is the ultimate goal of email marketing. He prioritizes revenue generation and engagement-based segmentation over open rate optimization. He even received a warning from Klaviyo for emailing too many unengaged subscribers but dismissed it because his focus is on revenue.

How does Nabeel Azeez segment email lists for ecommerce?

Azeez segments lists by engagement recency (e.g., last 7, 30, or 60-90 days) and by customer value, such as whales (high spenders), potential whales (frequent but lower spend), and lapsed whales. Each segment receives tailored messaging, and he ensures no overlap so each subscriber gets only one email per send.

What is Azeez's approach to unengaged subscribers?

He sets up a sunset automation that pauses subscribers who haven't engaged in 90 days, but he never unsubscribes them. Instead, he sends reactivation emails monthly or quarterly, and finds that about 10% of unengaged subscribers eventually return. He sometimes uses plain-text, educational emails to re-engage them.

How can a small ecommerce brand grow email revenue from $10,000 to $20,000 per month?

Azeez suggests increasing email frequency from three times per week to daily, provided the subscriber list is growing. He also recommends reviewing email automations for missed revenue opportunities and testing different opt-in offers. Additionally, he advises tracking email's impact on other channels, like Meta Ads, by switching attribution from last-click to first-click.

What are common email marketing mistakes Azeez sees in ecommerce?

Common mistakes include not testing opt-in pop-up offers enough and relying solely on discounts, which can train shoppers to expect them. Merchants also fail to segment aggressively or increase frequency when their list is growing. Azeez emphasizes the importance of engagement-based segmentation and tracking margins on promotional offers.

About this story

Topics covered
Published
31 Jul 2026
Originally published at