What it takes to succeed as a DTC brand today

This summary was written by ShopDigest AI from Glossy’s report, by Anna Hensel. Read the full story ↗
At the most recent Modern Retail+ and Glossy+ Town Hall, editorial staff and subscribers gathered to discuss the future of DTC.
Overview
A Modern Retail+ and Glossy+ Town Hall discussed what it takes to succeed as a DTC brand today. Panelists argued that DTC is now a state of mind rather than a strict sales model, with success hinging on customer relationships, product differentiation, and strategic channel choices. The discussion covered shifting discovery channels, the importance of customer feedback, and the role of selective wholesale partnerships.
Key Takeaways
- DTC brands can sell through third-party retailers like Target and Walmart if they maintain close customer relationships.
- Customer feedback and two-way dialogue are critical for informing next steps and building loyalty.
- Product differentiation is more important than ever; pretty packaging alone won't justify premium pricing.
- Wholesale partnerships should be strategic and limited, not numerous, to avoid wasted resources.
- Discovery channels are changing—brands must adapt to platforms like TikTok Shop.
Examples Cited
- Favorite Daughter: founder knows top 20 spenders by name and sends gifts to re-engage lapsed customers.
- Tin Can: a modern landline startup that grew through word-of-mouth via a truly differentiated product.
- Reformation: does 90% of revenue through its DTC site, a rare pure DTC model.
- Universal Standard and Merjuri: successful integrated models with selective wholesale partners like Anthropologie and Nordstrom.
Frequently asked questions
What does it mean to be a DTC brand today?
According to the article, DTC is now considered a state of mind rather than a strict sales model. A brand can still be considered DTC even if it sells through third-party retailers like Target and Walmart, as long as it has built a close relationship with its customers.
Why is product differentiation important for DTC brands?
Early DTC brands succeeded through Facebook advertising arbitrage, but that advantage is gone. Now, selling the same product in new packaging is not enough to justify premium prices, so brands need truly differentiated products to build loyalty and grow through word-of-mouth.
How should DTC brands approach wholesale partnerships?
Brands should be very strategic about which wholesale partners they choose, as wrong partnerships waste resources. Successful brands often use an integrated model with a handful of carefully selected wholesale channels, such as Universal Standard selling through Anthropologie or Merjuri launching a shop-in-shop at Nordstrom.
Where should DTC brands spend their advertising money?
The article notes that audience questions centered on whether to spend $100 on TikTok, Meta, or Amazon advertising. It does not provide a definitive answer but highlights that the places where people discover new products are changing, and startups need to keep up with the times.
How can DTC brands build customer loyalty?
Brands can build loyalty by listening to customer data and feedback, maintaining a two-way dialogue, and making customers feel heard. The article cites Favorite Daughter, whose founder knows her top 20 spenders by name and sends gifts to customers who haven't purchased recently.
