PriceMate – Make An Offer
by StartExecution
Free plan · From $7.99/mo · 7d trial
Pay What You Want Vs Magical Make an Offer: Which Shopify App Is Best For Your Store In October 2026?
Discover the power of Shopify apps as we compare Pay What You Want and Magical Make an Offer side by side. Evaluate their features, explore their unique benefits, compare their pricing plans and user ratings, and find the perfect fit for your business needs. Let's dive into the comparison table and unlock the possibilities that await your Shopify store.Show more
Magical Make an Offer leads on 4 of the 7 factors, including rating, total reviews and track record — 170 reviews at 4.7★ and a free plan — while Pay What You Want leads on budget and integrations. Read the full verdict
Comparison
Top Pay What You Want alternatives — detailed comparison
The table below highlights the crucial differences between Pay What You Want and similar other Shopify apps based on parameters like ratings, reviews, features, pricing, etc.
| Apps | Add app | ||
| General information | |||
| Ratings | 4.6 ★ (54 reviews) | 4.7 ★ (170 reviews) | |
| Developed by | Extendons | Magical Apps | |
| Launch date | 1 September 2020 | 6 November 2015 | |
| Pricing | Free, $4.99/month, $8.99/month | Free, $9/month, $199/month | |
| Objective | Choose Your Price, Better Deal, Set Your Price, Ask for Price | Button for Making Offers, Pay Your Desired Amount, Ask for a Quote | |
| Categories | Pricing quotes, Pricing optimization | Pricing quotes, Pricing optimization | |
| Key features & highlights | |||
| Purpose | With the Pay What You Want app, your customers can reconsider their buying choice based on price. | Simply attach 'Make an Offer' and 'Pay What you Want' buttons to your products. Receive offers and sell more items. | |
| Features list |
|
| |
| Highlights | — | — | |
| User reviews and ratings | |||
| Recommended | 85.2% | 95.3% | |
| Pros |
|
| |
| Cons |
|
| |
| Pricing and plans | |||
| Total pricing plans | 3 | 3 | |
| Free plan | Available | Available | |
| Free trial | Yes, for 7 day(s) | Yes, for 14 day(s) | |
| Technical information | |||
| Rating | 4.6 ★ | 4.7 ★ | |
| Total reviews | 54 | 170 | |
| Launch date | 1 September 2020 | 6 November 2015 | |
Pay What You Want vs Magical Make an Offer: Final Verdict
When choosing the ideal Shopify app for your business, both Pay What You Want and Magical Make an Offer offer unique strengths and considerations.
The choice between Pay What You Want and Magical Make an Offer depends on your specific needs and priorities. Consider your business requirements, goals, and the features that align most closely with your objectives. Take into account factors such as pricing, user reviews, support quality, and integrations while making a decision.
We recommend thoroughly exploring the features and functionalities of each app. Remember, what works best for one business may not be ideal for another.
Here's a breakdown of key factors to help you choose a winner.
| Factor | Priority | Pay What You Want | Magical Make an Offer | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Average Rating | High priority | — | Winner | Detail |
| Total Reviews | High priority | — | Winner | Detail |
| Launch Date | Low priority | — | Winner | Detail |
| Budget | High priority | Winner | — | Detail |
| Support Channel | Medium priority | — | Winner | Detail |
| Integrations | Medium priority | Winner | — | Detail |
| Trial Period | Low priority | Tied | Tied | Detail |
Average Rating
High priorityWhile considering user reviews, take note of the average ratings for Pay What You Want and Magical Make an Offer. These ratings reflect users' overall satisfaction and can provide valuable insights into the reliability and effectiveness of each app. In this case, Pay What You Want holds an average rating of 4.6 stars, whereas Magical Make an Offer has 4.7 star ratings.
🥇 Winner: Magical Make an Offer🥈 Runner Up: Pay What You Want
For complete details, see the Ratings and Reviews section.
Total Reviews
High priorityConsider the total number of reviews Pay What You Want and Magical Make an Offer have received. A higher number of reviews generally indicates a larger user base and more feedback, which can provide additional insights into the app's performance and user experience. Here, Pay What You Want has received a total of 54 reviews and Magical Make an Offer has 170 reviews.
🥇 Winner: Magical Make an Offer🥈 Runner Up: Pay What You Want
For complete details, see the Ratings and Reviews section.
Launch Date
Low priorityWhile not a direct measure of quality, consider the launch date of each app - Pay What You Want and Magical Make an Offer to gain some context. A more established app brings years of experience and refinement to the table, but it's important to balance this factor with the app's average rating and total reviews. Pay What You Want and Magical Make an Offer were launched on Sep 1, 2020 and Nov 6, 2015 respectively.
🥇 Winner: Magical Make an Offer🥈 Runner Up: Pay What You Want
For complete details, see the Overview of the Apps section.
Budget
High priorityTake the time to analyze your specific needs, budget for the same, and long-term goals to decide which plan fits your requirements. Here, Pay What You Want offers 3 pricing plans (1 free plan, 2 paid plans) with an average plan price of $4.66. Magical Make an Offer, on the other hand, has a total of 3 pricing plans (1 free plan, 2 paid plans) with an average plan price of $69.33.
🥇 Winner: Pay What You Want🥈 Runner Up: Magical Make an Offer
For complete details, see the Pricing Details section.
Support Channel
Medium priorityBoth Pay What You Want and Magical Make an Offer provide customer support through various channels, such as email, live chat, FAQs section, or phone. A higher number of support channels indicates better accessibility and assistance, ensuring timely help whenever you need it. Here, the two apps offer the following support channels:
Pay What You Want2 support options
Magical Make an Offer3 support options
🥇 Winner: Magical Make an Offer🥈 Runner Up: Pay What You Want
For complete details, see the Support section.
Integrations
Medium priorityEvaluate the integration capabilities of Pay What You Want and Magical Make an Offer. Consider the number and variety of integration options they offer with other tools and services - more integration options can provide flexibility and streamline your workflows. Both apps offer various integration options with popular Shopify tools and services.
Pay What You Want6 integrations
Magical Make an Offer2 integrations
🥇 Winner: Pay What You Want🥈 Runner Up: Magical Make an Offer
For complete details, see the Integrations section.
Trial Period
Low priorityFree trial periods allow you to explore the app's features and functionalities before committing. Pay What You Want comes with a 7-day free trial period. Magical Make an Offer, on the other hand, comes with a 14-day free trial period. Take advantage of these trial periods to assess how well each app aligns with your specific business needs.
🥇 Winner: Pay What You Want, Magical Make an Offer🥈 Runner Up: N/A
For complete details, see the Features section.
By comparing and weighing these factors, you can make an informed decision and determine the winner between Pay What You Want and Magical Make an Offer that aligns best with your requirements and preferences for a successful Shopify app experience.
Shopify Apps Detailed Comparison: Pay What You Want vs Magical Make an Offer
In this comprehensive comparison, we'll delve into the details of two Shopify apps: Pay What You Want and Magical Make an Offer. Whether you're seeking to optimize marketing efforts, streamline operations, or improve customer engagement, our in-depth analysis will help you make an informed decision.
OverviewPay What You Want vs Magical Make an Offer
Let's dive into the overview of these two apps: Pay What You Want and Magical Make an Offer, and uncover how these Shopify apps can elevate your online business and empower you with powerful tools and features.
Pay What You Want Overview
Pay What You Want is a Shopify app developed by Unknown Developer to help merchants with Choose Your Price, Better Deal, Set Your Price, Ask for Price. With an average rating of 4.6 stars from 54 reviews, Pay What You Want is one of the top-rated Pricing quotes Shopify apps.
Launch DateSep 1, 2020
PurposeWith the Pay What You Want app, your customers can reconsider their buying choice based on price.
Pricing summaryFree plan available. Free trial available.
Magical Make an Offer Overview
Magical Make an Offer is a Shopify app developed by Unknown Developer to help merchants with Button for Making Offers, Pay Your Desired Amount, Ask for a Quote. With an average rating of 4.7 stars from 170 reviews, Magical Make an Offer is one of the top-rated Pricing quotes Shopify apps.
Launch DateNov 6, 2015
PurposeSimply attach 'Make an Offer' and 'Pay What you Want' buttons to your products. Receive offers and sell more items.
Pricing summaryFree to install. Free trial available.
Features ComparisonPay What You Want vs Magical Make an Offer
While both apps are designed to optimize your Shopify store, their intended uses may vary. Let's take a more in-depth look at each of these apps' features.
Pay What You Want Features
- Turn on PWYW so customers can set their own price.
- Set up a price limit range.
- You may add an “Ask Your Price/Make an Offer” button.
- Customize alert messages for users.
- Add buttons that take users straight from the catalog to the Cart or Checkout page.
Magical Make an Offer Features
- Add a "Make an Offer" button to your items.
- Boost your odds of making a successful sale.
- Create rules to automatically accept, reject or negotiate offers.
- Utilize exit popups to prompt customers to propose a deal.
- Change the design and content of your messages to match your brand.
Pricing PlansPay What You Want vs Magical Make an Offer
There are tons of Shopify apps for small businesses and enterprises alike. From Pay What You Want to Magical Make an Offer, each offers a range of pricing packages to accommodate different business needs.
Let's see how the prices of Pay What You Want and Magical Make an Offer measure up.
Pay What You Want Pricing Details
Pay What You Want has 3 pricing plans: 1 free and 2 paid. The paid plans cost $4.99/ month, $8.99/ month and come with a 7-day free trial period.
30-Days Free Trial
$0 /month
- Free for all store plans
- Apply to 1 Product
- Access all core plan features
- Support via Whatsapp Chat
Core
$4.99 /month
- Apply on unlimited products & collection
- 1 widget customization for offer display
- 1 button animation for make an offer
- Redirect user to cart & checkout page
- Easy storewide rule-based management
Spark
$8.99 /month
- All Core plan included
- Multiple widget customizations
- 3+ widget customization for offer displa
- Multiple make an offer button animation
- Show Make an Offer PWYW by Country
Magical Make an Offer Pricing Details
Magical Make an Offer has 3 pricing plans: 1 free and 2 paid. The paid plans cost $9/ month, $199/ month and come with a 14-day free trial period.
Starter
$0 /month
- For stores getting started with offers
- Best when selling under $2K/month
- Unlimited offers on products and orders
- Product and order eligibility rules
- Auto-accept, decline, and counter rules
Growth
$9 /month
- For growing stores that want lower fees
- Best when selling $2K-$20K/month
- Everything in Starter
Power
$199 /month
- For high-volume stores that want no fees
- Best when selling $20K+/month
- Everything in Starter
User RatingsPay What You Want vs Magical Make an Offer
User feedback and reviews play a crucial role in assessing the quality and effectiveness of any Shopify app. Let's take a closer look at what users are saying about Pay What You Want and Magical Make an Offer.
Pay What You Want Ratings
Pay What You Want has garnered an overall rating of 4.6 stars from a total of 54 reviews on the Shopify app store.
4.6★★★★★| 54 reviews
Of the total reviews, 92% are positive, 8% are neutral, and 8% are negative.
✨ AI Summary of Pay What You Want Reviews
The app enables Shopify stores to implement a "pay what you want" or custom pricing model, allowing customers to enter their desired price for products or services directly on product pages or as an invoice payment tool. It supports flexible pricing for donations, prepaid services, or custom orders, with seamless integration into existing store workflows. Key strengths include highly responsive and proactive customer support, which often resolves issues quickly, including theme compatibility, custom feature requests, and technical glitches. The app is praised for its straightforward setup, clean design, and ability to handle unique use cases like nonprofit donations or invoice-based payments. However, limitations include occasional compatibility issues with other apps or themes, slower load times impacting site performance, and inventory management inconsistencies when purchases bypass the cart. Some users report unexpected behavior, such as duplicate product listings when custom prices are applied. Despite these drawbacks, the app stands out for its niche functionality and exceptional support, making it a preferred choice for businesses needing flexible pricing solutions.
Magical Make an Offer Ratings
Magical Make an Offer has garnered an overall rating of 4.7 stars from a total of 170 reviews on the Shopify app store.
4.7★★★★★| 170 reviews
Of the total reviews, 94% are positive, 6% are neutral, and 6% are negative.
✨ AI Summary of Magical Make an Offer Reviews
This Shopify app enables merchants to facilitate price negotiations by allowing customers to submit offers directly on product pages. Its core functionality includes automated or manual offer management, with options to accept, reject, or counter offers, enhancing customer engagement and conversion rates. The app is praised for its ease of setup, seamless integration with Shopify themes, and responsive customer support, which often assists with customization requests. Key strengths include increased sales, particularly for higher-ticket items, and the ability to capture leads through interactive pricing. However, some limitations include occasional technical bugs, lack of multilingual support, and inconsistent notification systems. A few users note issues with shipping cost integration and occasional lowball offers. Despite these drawbacks, the app is widely regarded as a valuable tool for businesses seeking flexible pricing strategies.
Pros and ConsPay What You Want vs Magical Make an Offer
Let's explore the pros and cons of Pay What You Want and Magical Make an Offer to better understand their strengths and limitations.
Pay What You Want Pros and Cons
Pros
- Quick, responsive, and helpful assistance with issues and customizations.
- Seamlessly handles manual invoice payments for custom services.
- Adapts to unique business needs with tailored solutions.
- Technical problems are addressed promptly, often within hours.
- Easy installation and straightforward configuration for most users.
- Effectively supports pay-what-you-want campaigns and custom pricing.
- Enhances customer trust through flexible payment options.
Cons
- Some users report significant delays in app responsiveness.
- Occasional problems with automatic inventory updates during purchases.
- Creates duplicate product entries for custom payments, complicating inventory.
Magical Make an Offer Pros and Cons
Pros
- Significant increase in sales and customer engagement reported by multiple users.
- Facilitates negotiation and interaction with potential buyers, enhancing conversion rates.
- Quick and straightforward installation process with minimal technical hurdles.
- Highly praised for fast, helpful, and personalized customer service.
- Flexible options to tailor the app’s appearance and functionality to match store themes.
- Seamless compatibility with Shopify and various themes.
- Offers useful tools like automated responses, counteroffers, and email notifications.
- Intuitive interface appreciated by both store owners and customers.
- Effective in capturing leads and converting offers into sales.
- Consistently performs as expected with minimal errors.
Cons
- Some users experienced technical glitches, including crashes and functionality issues.
- Lack of multilingual options noted by non-English store owners.
- Problems with text alerts for new offers, requiring manual checks.
- Concerns over the 2% transaction fee, especially for high-ticket items.
- Customization gaps, such as unchangeable white backgrounds on dark themes.
Featured IntegrationsPay What You Want vs Magical Make an Offer
Seamless integration with other tools and platforms is crucial for maximizing the functionality and efficiency of your Shopify store. Let's explore the integration capabilities of Pay What You Want and Magical Make an Offer, and see how effortlessly these apps can enhance your store operations.
Pay What You Want Integrations
Pay What You Want offers a wide range of integration options, allowing you to connect with popular third-party tools and services seamlessly. The developer has provided an extensive list of integration tools:
Shopify Admineasy donationsmake an offername your pricepay what you wantpwyw
Magical Make an Offer Integrations
Magical Make an Offer offers a wide range of integration options, allowing you to connect with popular third-party tools and services seamlessly. The developer has provided an extensive list of integration tools:
Shopify AdminGoogle Analytics
SupportPay What You Want vs Magical Make an Offer
The support team plays a vital role in resolving queries, offering guidance, and addressing concerns related to Pay What You Want and Magical Make an Offer. Their expertise and responsiveness are key considerations for ensuring a seamless app experience.
Pay What You Want User Support
For any inquiries or assistance regarding Pay What You Want, their dedicated support team is here to assist you. You can reach out to them via email at [email protected].
Magical Make an Offer User Support
For any inquiries or assistance regarding Magical Make an Offer, their dedicated support team is here to assist you. You can reach out to them via email at [email protected]. To address common concerns, Magical Make an Offer offers an extensive FAQ section on its website, providing helpful information and troubleshooting tips.
Need assistance in choosing the right app for your store?
Trust ShopDigest to provide the expertise and support you need to make the most of your chosen Shopify app.
1
Send your details
Your name, email and store domain go straight to the Extendons team.
2
The developer gets in touch
Extendons contacts you directly to arrange setup for your store.
3
Install at your own pace
Perfect your store’s functionality without the pressure to move on until you’re ready.
FAQs for Pay What You Want and Magical Make an Offer
1. What is the key difference between these Shopify apps: Pay What You Want and Magical Make an Offer?
When comparing various Shopify apps, their main objective sets them apart. Pay What You Want is designed to help merchants with Choose Your Price, Better Deal, Set Your Price, Ask for Price. On the other hand, Magical Make an Offer focuses on Button for Making Offers, Pay Your Desired Amount, Ask for a Quote. Assessing these differences will help you determine which app aligns best with your unique business needs.
2. Which app between Pay What You Want and Magical Make an Offer offers free pricing plan options for Shopify merchants?
Pay What You Want has 1 free plan. Magical Make an Offer has 1 free plan.
3. What are the pricing plans for Pay What You Want and Magical Make an Offer?
While the specific pricing plans may vary for each app, here's a general breakdown:
Pay What You Want offers a total of 3 pricing plans: 1 free plan and 2 paid plans. Paid plan costs: $4.99/ month, $8.99/ month. Free plan cost: Free.
Magical Make an Offer offers a total of 3 pricing plans: 1 free plan and 2 paid plans. Paid plan costs: $9/ month, $199/ month. Free plan cost: Free.
4. Is there a free trial available for Pay What You Want and Magical Make an Offer?
Pay What You Want comes with a 7-day free trial period. Magical Make an Offer, on the other hand, comes with a 14-day free trial period.
5. What are the integration options available for Pay What You Want and Magical Make an Offer?
Pay What You Want: Shopify Admin, easy donations, make an offer, name your price, pay what you want, pwyw.
Magical Make an Offer: Shopify Admin, Google Analytics.
6. What are the support options available for Pay What You Want and Magical Make an Offer?
Pay What You Want · Email: [email protected] · Website: https://www.extendons.com
Magical Make an Offer · Email: [email protected] · Website: https://www.magicalapps.com/ · FAQ: https://www.magicalapps.com/frequently-asked-questions-magical-make-an-offer-app/
7. Are Pay What You Want and Magical Make an Offer compatible with my Shopify theme?
Generally, Pay What You Want and Magical Make an Offer are designed to be compatible with most Shopify themes. However, it is always advisable to review the app documentation or contact the app's support team to ensure seamless integration with your specific theme.
8. Which app between Pay What You Want and Magical Make an Offer is better?
Determining which app between Pay What You Want and Magical Make an Offer is better depends on your specific business requirements. It is recommended to thoroughly evaluate each app based on various factors such as customer reviews, support, integrations, and functionalities to make an informed decision that aligns best with your unique requirements.
Alternatives
Offerly: Make An Offer Button!
by Nakatomi Apps
Free to install · From $20/mo · 14d trial
Most popular
Most popular Shopify apps on the market
by Judge.me
Product reviews with pictures and videos for credibility and search engine optimization.
Free plan · From $15/mo · 15d trial
by TikTok Inc.
Display your products to billions of TikTok users.
Free
by Shopify
Simplify all tasks and focus on your business.
Free
by Shopify
Increase your brand visibility and communicate with customers on Shop.
Free
Compared in this guide
Pay What You Want
4.6 ★ · 54 reviews · Free plan
Magical Make an Offer
4.7 ★ · 170 reviews · Free plan
Verdict at a glance
Magical Make an Offer takes 4 of the 7 comparison factors, including rating, total reviews and track record. Pay What You Want leads on budget and integrations.
🥇 Winner: Magical Make an Offer🥈 Runner Up: Pay What You Want
About ShopDigest
The Shopify ecosystem, shown through the work
ShopDigest is an independent directory of Shopify work. Developers, agencies and experts publish the projects they’ve actually shipped — migrations, rebuilds, custom apps, headless storefronts — with the results attached.
For merchants, that means judging a partner on evidence instead of a sales page: browse real builds in your category and budget, then reach out directly. For builders, it means one profile that keeps working after the project ships.
No commissions, no pay-to-rank placements. The best work rises because people save and follow it.
More about ShopDigestAbout ShopDigest
Show the work.
Win the work.
A portfolio directory for the Shopify ecosystem — builders publish, merchants browse, nobody buys a better position.