Pay What You Want Shopify Apps — Full Rankings Table
All tracked pay what you want Shopify apps ranked by current App Store position, with rank change vs 30 days ago and Leader / Climbing / Declining / Stable status — filterable by date range, sortable by rank or rank change.
| App | Rank | Status |
|---|---|---|
 Pay What You Want | 1– | Leader |
 Magical Make an Offer | 2– | Stable |
 Paylet: Pay What You Want | 3– | Stable |
 Pluginos Pay What You Want | 4– | Stable |
 Offer Your Price ‑ Make Offers | 5– | Stable |
 PriceMate – Make An Offer | 6– | Stable |
 Offero Make Offer & Best Offer | 73 | Climbing |
 Mega Better Price | 81 | Declining |
 Price Negotiator ‑ Make Offer | 9– | Stable |
 Addify ‑ Name Your Price | 102 | Declining |
Showing 1-10 out of 96
Key Insights:
- Pay What You Want ranks #1 for pay what you want Shopify apps — 1 position ahead of Magical Make an Offer at #2.
- Among the top 10 tracked pay what you want apps, 1 climbed and 2 declined in rank over the past 30 days — a settled top tier.
- Offero Make Offer & Best Offer is the biggest climber, gaining 3 positions this month to reach #7.
- Addify ‑ Name Your Price dropped 2 positions this month to #10 — the largest single decliner in the top 10 pay what you want apps.
Pay What You Want Shopify Apps — Ranking Position Over Time
Monthly ranking trajectory for the top 5 pay what you want Shopify apps over the past year — pick any apps, change date range, or switch to Ranking Changes to see per-interval movement.
Charts Data
| App | May 2026 | Jun 2026 | Jul 2026 | Aug 2026 | Sep 2026 | Oct 2026 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pay What You Want | #1– | #1– | #1– | #1– | #1– | #1– |
| Magical Make an Offer | #2– | #2– | #2– | #2– | #2– | #2– |
| Paylet: Pay What You Want | #43 | #62 | #42 | #31 | #3– | #3– |
| Pluginos Pay What You Want | — | — | — | #4– | #4– | #4– |
| Offer Your Price ‑ Make Offers | #52 | #41 | #51 | #5– | #5– | #5– |
Key Insights:
- Pay What You Want's ranking held steady from #1 to #1 over the charted period.
- 1 of 5 top pay what you want apps improved their position; 1 declined — a stable market.
Top Pay What You Want Shopify Apps by Current Ranking
Pay What You Want holds the #1 position for pay what you want Shopify apps. Magical Make an Offer sits at #2 and Paylet: Pay What You Want at #3, rounding out the top tier. Offero Make Offer & Best Offer is the standout mover this month, climbing 3 positions to #7 — a momentum signal worth tracking.
Stable rankings in pay what you want mean Shopify merchants have largely settled on their preferences for this category — challengers ranked below the top 10 face an uphill path to break in without a meaningfully differentiated feature set, integration depth, or pricing model.
Long-Term Ranking Trends Across Pay What You Want Shopify Apps
Pay What You Want held #1 steadily across the charted period — an entrenched leader in pay what you want that competitors haven't displaced. Among the top 5 plotted pay what you want apps, 1 improved and 1 declined — rankings reshuffled without a single category-wide direction.
Stable rankings across the top 5 apps mean pay what you want merchants have largely settled on their preferred apps — challengers below the top 5 face an uphill path to break in.
Top 5 Apps in Pay What You Want
- Pay What You Want — Holds the #1 pay what you want ranking on the Shopify App Store, rated 4.6★.
- Magical Make an Offer — Ranks #2 for pay what you want on the Shopify App Store, rated 4.7★.
- Paylet: Pay What You Want — Ranks #3 for pay what you want on the Shopify App Store, rated 5.0★.
- Pluginos Pay What You Want — Ranks #4 for pay what you want on the Shopify App Store.
- Offer Your Price ‑ Make Offers — Ranks #5 for pay what you want on the Shopify App Store, rated 4.4★.
Pay What You Want Shopify Apps — Frequently Asked Questions
1. Which pay what you want app ranks #1 on Shopify?
Pay What You Want currently ranks #1 for pay what you want apps on the Shopify App Store and holds 57.2% market share (-4.49pp vs 30 days ago). Rankings refresh weekly — see the trend chart above for how this position has changed over time.
2. How are pay what you want Shopify apps ranked?
Rankings on this page reflect each app's position in Shopify's keyword search results for "pay what you want", which Shopify computes from a mix of merchant install volume, review velocity, and recency. Apps beyond position #22 receive zero traffic in our market share calculation since merchants rarely scroll that far.
3. Which pay what you want apps are climbing the rankings on Shopify?
Offero Make Offer & Best Offer has shown the strongest ranking momentum among pay what you want apps, climbing 3 positions to #7 over the past 30 days. Sort the rankings table by Rank Change (Low to High) to surface the full set of recent gainers.
4. How often do pay what you want app rankings change on Shopify?
Pay What You Want rankings have been notably stable over the past 30 days — most of the top 5 held their positions, suggesting an established competitive order. Rankings are crawled weekly, so significant moves usually take 2–4 weeks to show up.
5. Which pay what you want apps lost rank positions recently?
Addify ‑ Name Your Price dropped the most among the top 10 tracked pay what you want apps, slipping 2 positions to #10 over the past 30 days. Switch the table sub-tab to "Ranking Changes" to see all decliners ordered by movement size.
6. How many pay what you want apps does ShopDigest track on Shopify?
ShopDigest tracks 96 pay what you want apps on the Shopify App Store. The full list is paginated in the table above — adjust the date range and sort order to drill into any window.
7. Why don't apps ranked beyond #22 show market share for pay what you want?
For keyword pages, market share is rank-weighted: position #1 carries roughly 40× the weight of position #22, and apps beyond #22 receive zero weight. This reflects Shopify search behaviour — merchants almost never scroll past the top of the results, so positions further down don't translate to installs.
