Magical Make an Offer Shopify App Alternatives December 2025
Are you currently using Magical Make an Offer for your Shopify store, but you're curious about other options available in the market? Look no further! We present you with 11 outstanding alternatives to Magical Make an Offer, carefully selected to meet a variety of e-commerce needs.
Top Magical Make an Offer alternatives
- Free Gift Box+Buy 1 Get 1+BOGO:
Let customers include a complimentary gift with their purchase.
- S:Request a Quote & Hide Price:
Ask for a Quote, Fast Quote, Phone for Price, Propose a Price
- AI Request a Quote, Hide Price:
Ask for Price, Conceal Price, Conceal Add to Cart & Request for Price
- Quotify: Request a Quote:
Ask for a quote, turn quote into order, conceal price/add to cart.
- Pay What You Want:
Choose Your Price, Better Deal, Set Your Price, Ask for Price
- Offerly: Make an Offer Button!:
Add "Make Offer" Button to your products to increase sales!
- PricePitch: Offers & Close:
Empower your customers to choose their price, You set the rule
- Deals Promotion Platform:
Attract new orders by offering your deals to customers at no cost.
- PriceMate – Make An Offer:
Add Make an Offer Widget to product and get Custom Offers
- SellBuzz : Upsell & Cross‑sell:
Can display relevant products as a special offer to suitable customers.
Free Gift Box+Buy 1 Get 1+BOGO
Let customers include a complimentary gift with their purchase.
Free Trial: 7 days
Pros
Highly responsive and helpful support team, frequently praised for quick resolutions.
Simple setup and intuitive interface, often highlighted as user-friendly.
Valued for being a cost-free solution with robust features.
Cons
Issues like currency recognition errors, ghost products, and checkout malfunctions.
Store Owner's Tip
Save more — we help you find hidden deals.
22
SD Points
4.00%
Market Share
S:Request a Quote & Hide Price
Ask for a Quote, Fast Quote, Phone for Price, Propose a Price
Free Trial: 7 days
Pros
Rapid response times and effective problem resolution are consistently highlighted.
The app offers comprehensive functionality, including advanced features even in the free plan.
Users frequently note the straightforward installation and intuitive configuration process.
Cons
Some users report missed leads due to unreliable email alerts.
Store Owner's Tip
Save more — we help you find hidden deals.
15
SD Points
2.23%
Market Share
AI Request a Quote, Hide Price
Ask for Price, Conceal Price, Conceal Add to Cart & Request for Price
Free Trial: 7 days
Pros
Highly responsive and helpful support team, frequently praised for quick resolutions and personalized assistance.
Simple setup and intuitive interface, often highlighted as user-friendly even for non-technical users.
Reliably hides prices and replaces them with quote requests, meeting core user needs.
Cons
Some users report prices still visible in certain scenarios, like product recommendations.
Store Owner's Tip
Save more — we help you find hidden deals.
58
SD Points
2.52%
Market Share
Quotify: Request a Quote
Ask for a quote, turn quote into order, conceal price/add to cart.
Free Trial: 7 days
Pros
Consistently praised for responsiveness, professionalism, and problem-solving efficiency.
Clean, easy-to-navigate design with a seamless front-end experience.
Offers extensive options for personalizing forms, languages, and branding.
Cons
Some found initial setup confusing without guidance.
Store Owner's Tip
Save more — we help you find hidden deals.
29
SD Points
1.20%
Market Share
Pay What You Want
Choose Your Price, Better Deal, Set Your Price, Ask for Price
Free Trial: 3 days
Pros
Quick, responsive, and helpful assistance with issues and customizations.
Seamlessly handles manual invoice payments for custom services.
Adapts to unique business needs with tailored solutions.
Cons
Some users report significant delays in app responsiveness.
Store Owner's Tip
Save more — we help you find hidden deals.
118
SD Points
0.86%
Market Share
Offerly: Make an Offer Button!
Add "Make Offer" Button to your products to increase sales!
Free Trial: 14 days
Pros
Rapid response times and personalized assistance are consistently highlighted.
The "make an offer" feature significantly boosts conversions and customer engagement.
Seamless setup and compatibility with existing store themes without requiring customization.
Cons
Conflicts with other apps (e.g., pre-order tools) causing functionality disruptions.
Store Owner's Tip
Save more — we help you find hidden deals.
32
SD Points
0.84%
Market Share
PricePitch: Offers & Close
Empower your customers to choose their price, You set the rule
Key Features
Add Pitch Your Price button and let customers pitch their price for a product.
Set predefined rules for automatically accepting, rejecting, or countering pitch
Customise the messaging and style of a pitch interface to align with your brand.
Use negotiated pricing to turn more visitors into buyers.
Hide standard checkout and add-to-cart buttons to encourage custom pricing.
Store Owner's Tip
Save more — we help you find hidden deals.
0
SD Points
0.15%
Market Share
Deals Promotion Platform
Attract new orders by offering your deals to customers at no cost.
Key Features
PriceMate – Make An Offer
Add Make an Offer Widget to product and get Custom Offers
Pros
Responsive and helpful support team, often praised for quick issue resolution and customization assistance.
Wide range of features and customization options, including appearance and language settings.
Quick adoption and execution of user-suggested features, enhancing usability.
Cons
Some users encountered security alerts from antivirus software, blocking access to certain app functionalities.
Store Owner's Tip
Save more — we help you find hidden deals.
25
SD Points
0.31%
Market Share
SellBuzz : Upsell & Cross‑sell
Can display relevant products as a special offer to suitable customers.
Free Trial: 7 days
Pros
Quick and helpful responses from the support team resolved initial setup issues.
The app performs well on desktop, with a visually appealing and functional design.
Competitive pricing compared to similar apps, offering good value for the features provided.
Cons
Reports of unresolved bugs, inconsistent performance across devices, and missing features.
Store Owner's Tip
Save more — we help you find hidden deals.
0
SD Points
0.01%
Market Share
Showing 1-10 out of 11
About Magical Make an Offer
Magical Make an Offer is a versatile Shopify app designed to help achieve the purpose: “Simply attach 'Make an Offer' and 'Pay What you Want' buttons to your products. Receive offers and sell more items.”. This Shopify app is listed under Pricing quotes category. It has garnered over 170 reviews with an average rating of 4.5 stars from Shopify merchants.
Some of its key features include:
- ✅Offer Button Addition: Add a "Make an Offer" button to your items.
- ✅Increase sale success: Boost your odds of making a successful sale.
- ✅Automated Negotiation Rules: Create rules to automatically accept, reject or negotiate offers.
- ✅Exit Popups Strategy: Utilize exit popups to prompt customers to propose a deal.
- ✅Brand Customization: Change the design and content of your messages to match your brand.
Besides, Magical Make an Offer is known for its Significant increase in sales and customer engagement reported by multiple users., Facilitates negotiation and interaction with potential buyers, enhancing conversion rates., Quick and straightforward installation process with minimal technical hurdles., Highly praised for fast, helpful, and personalized customer service., Flexible options to tailor the app’s appearance and functionality to match store themes., Seamless compatibility with Shopify and various themes., Offers useful tools like automated responses, counteroffers, and email notifications., Intuitive interface appreciated by both store owners and customers., Effective in capturing leads and converting offers into sales., Consistently performs as expected with minimal errors..
Why Consider Magical Make an Offer Alternatives for Shopify?
While Magical Make an Offer may have its unique features and benefits, it's essential to periodically reevaluate your options to ensure that you're using the best tools to optimize your online store. Here are some reasons why you should explore Magical Make an Offer alternatives:
Diverse Needs: What worked initially with Magical Make an Offer may not fully address your current needs. By considering Magical Make an Offer alternatives, you can find apps that are better suited to your changing objectives.
Budget Constraints: While considering alternatives to Magical Make an Offer can impact your budget significantly. Some alternatives offer similar functionality at the same or reduced pricing level, while others may provide increased pricing but with added features that justify the investment.
Compatibility Issues: If you have encountered compatibility issues with Magical Make an Offer or have concerns about its integration with other essential tools and themes, exploring Magical Make an Offer alternatives can help you find apps that offer better compatibility and ease of use.
Feature Enhancement: Alternatives to Magical Make an Offer may offer innovative features that can give your Shopify store a competitive edge. By exploring these alternatives, you can tap into new capabilities and stay ahead in the dynamic e-commerce landscape.
In the following sections, we'll introduce you to some of the top alternatives to Magical Make an Offer.
Overview of the Best Magical Make an Offer Shopify Alternatives
There are several alternatives in the Shopify app store that can seamlessly replace or complement Magical Make an Offer. Whether you are looking for a change or just exploring your options, you are bound to find the perfect fit for your Shopify store. We have listed the top Shopify Magical Make an Offer alternatives based on their popularity and average rating.
| App Name | Developer | Starting Price | Free Plan | Reviews |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Free Gift Box+Buy 1 Get 1+BOGO | GoodApps | $0/month | Available | 4.6 (144) |
| S:Request a Quote & Hide Price | Storeify | $0/month | Available | 4.9 (108) |
| AI Request a Quote, Hide Price | SetuBridge | $0/month | Available | 4.7 (148) |
| Quotify: Request a Quote | AppHive | $17/month | Unavailable | 4.7 (68) |
| Pay What You Want | Extendons | $4.99/month | Unavailable | 4.2 (46) |
| Offerly: Make an Offer Button! | Nakatomi Apps | $0/month | Available | 4.9 (54) |
| PricePitch: Offers & Close | TechOps | $0/month | Available | 5.0 (2) |
| Deals Promotion Platform | $0/month | Unavailable | 4.2 (15) | |
| PriceMate – Make An Offer | StartExecution | $0/month | Unavailable | 4.5 (20) |
| SellBuzz : Upsell & Cross‑sell | SolverCircle | $5.99/month | Unavailable | 3.0 (2) |
Have a Closer Look at the Best Alternatives to Magical Make an Offer
Now let us jump in and check out these top Magical Make an Offer alternatives.
1. Free Gift Box+Buy 1 Get 1+BOGO
4.6
(144)
Install Now
Our experts are here to help you.
2. S:Request a Quote & Hide Price
4.9
(108)
Install Now
Our experts are here to help you.
3. AI Request a Quote, Hide Price
4.7
(148)
Install Now
Our experts are here to help you.
4. Quotify: Request a Quote
4.7
(68)
Install Now
Our experts are here to help you.
5. Pay What You Want
4.2
(46)
Install Now
Our experts are here to help you.
6. Offerly: Make an Offer Button!
4.9
(54)
Install Now
Our experts are here to help you.
7. PricePitch: Offers & Close
5.0
(2)
Install Now
Our experts are here to help you.
8. Deals Promotion Platform
4.2
(15)
Install Now
Our experts are here to help you.
9. PriceMate – Make An Offer
4.5
(20)
Install Now
Our experts are here to help you.
10. SellBuzz : Upsell & Cross‑sell
3.0
(2)
Install Now
Our experts are here to help you.
How to Choose the Right Magical Make an Offer Alternative for Your Shopify Store
Choosing the right alternative to Magical Make an Offer for your Shopify store is a crucial decision that can significantly impact your e-commerce operations. To help you make an informed choice, consider the following factors.
Identify Your Needs: Make a list of features, integrations, or improvements you seek in a Magical Make an Offer alternative. Understanding your needs will serve as a guide when evaluating alternatives.
Compare Features: Compare the features of each alternative to Magical Make an Offer and see how they align with your needs. Pay attention to unique functionalities that may differentiate one alternative from another.
Check Reviews and User Feedback: Look for reviews from Shopify store owners who have used the Magical Make an Offer alternatives you are considering. Pay attention to both positive and negative comments to get a well-rounded view.
Pricing: Consider your budget and choose a Magical Make an Offer alternative that fits within your financial constraints. Some alternatives may be cost-effective, while others may be feature-rich but come at a higher price.
Scalability: Consider the long-term scalability of Magical Make an Offer alternatives. Choose an alternative that can adapt to your growing store needs.
Trial Period: If available, take advantage of any trial periods offered by Magical Make an Offer alternatives. Hands-on experience is invaluable in assessing usability, compatibility with your Shopify setup, and overall user-friendliness.
Support and Updates: Research the responsiveness of the support team behind each Magical Make an Offer alternative. Ensure that the alternative you choose has a responsive support team and receives regular updates.
Remember that the best Magical Make an Offer Shopify alternative will address your current requirements and position your store for future success.
More Information on Magical Make an Offer Shopify Alternatives
As you embark on your journey to find the perfect Magical Make an Offer alternative, the right choice can elevate your Shopify store's performance, enhance your customer shopping experience, and position you for growth in the competitive e-commerce landscape.
We've introduced you to a curated list of top Magical Make an Offer alternatives, each with its own strengths and advantages. Whether you're seeking a cost-effective solution or a feature-rich paid alternative, you have plenty of options to choose from.
Choosing the right Magical Make an Offer alternative requires careful consideration of your specific requirements, budget, and long-term goals. You can gain deeper insights into your selected apps by visiting our app comparison page. If you need expert guidance, ShopDigest can help you navigate this process effectively, from identifying your needs to assessing compatibility and support.
Magical Make an Offer Shopify Alternative Installation
There are thousands of Magical Make an Offer alternatives with different installation instructions, integration complexities, and customization levels. Our team at ShopDigest is here to assist you every step of the way. Installing your chosen app is a breeze with our service, ensuring a seamless integration into your store's ecosystem.
What's included
- Safely install/uninstall Shopify alternative app of your choice
- App integration with any theme as per specification
- Configurations & setup
- Assured support and guidance
- Get discount offers (not guaranteed)
What's not included
- Shopify Magical Make an Offer alternative app subscription cost
Connect with us to harness the full potential of your selected Magical Make an Offer Shopify Alternative without any hassle.
Frequently Asked Questions for Magical Make an Offer Shopify Alternatives
Free Alternatives to Magical Make an Offer
Looking for a no-cost alternative to Magical Make an Offer? We've curated a list of free Magical Make an Offer alternatives that provide a wide range of functionalities at no charge. It's perfect for startups and small businesses looking to maximize their e-commerce potential without paying a penny. Check out the full list here.